Deductibles and Replacement Car Coverage

Rob Auernig • September 9, 2025

September 2025 Blog

Deductibles and Replacement Car Coverage


Deductibles and Replacement Car (rental car) Coverage are two variables in your insurance policy that may warrant further review.


Typically, a higher deductible lowers your monthly payment, while a lower one raises the monthly cost. Likewise, adding rental coverage will also add to the monthly expense of your insurance.


However, we find that most of our insured customers think they have rental coverage, only to find out after an incident that they do not. That can be a rude awakening during an already-stressful situation.


There are also a variety of levels of rental coverage. Some insurance companies may limit the dollar amount or only pay a percentage of rental expense (and ONLY if a rental is utilized), while others may give a daily allowance whether or not a vehicle is actually utilized. Generally, in each case there are limits to the number of days that will be allowed. However, for a claimant (a person making a claim against another’s insurance policy), there are typically no such limitations other than policy limits.


Nevertheless, policy limits have become an issue over recent years. This year, California raised minimum property damage coverage from $5,000 to $15,000. That means that if you are hit by a minimally covered driver, your claim against their insurance would cap out at $15K, including rental expense. If there was another car involved, your share is pro-rated and may be significantly less. Oftentimes, this issue doesn’t become apparent for days or weeks, which means that the rental expense could end up coming out of your pocket if your own coverage lacks replacement vehicle allowance.


Ideally, we are fully aware of our insurance costs and exposure. Although the reality is that most of us are only aware of the costs, and we assume that our exposure is minimal.


Therefore, in the short term, it would be best to review your policy and remind yourself of those coverages that you selected back when you purchased your policy. The best option is to review your policy with your agent. Many of you know that I am a big fan of agents. Agents are likely the only ones within the company that truly care about you as a client, and a healthy relationship with an insurance agent can save you money and relieve stress.


Agents are the experts that are looking out for your interests and adjusting your exposure to that of your choosing. But what if you have one of those agentless insurance companies? One option would be to have your current policy reviewed by an agent of another company to get a price quote. Most agents will review your policy free of charge and may offer advice to reduce exposure or save money.


In the chaos of customers dealing with insurance claims departments, we often get asked, “What’s the best insurance company?”. The answer is always, “the ones with the best agents.”

A good agent will help hold their company accountable to the provisions of the policy and state laws and regulations in the event of a claims department trying to get away with something at your expense. They can also provide you with the price of changing your deductibles or rental coverages to give peace of mind in the event of an unfortunate incident.


Feel free to give us a call if you need a referral to a good agent!


I hope you find this helpful!


Drive Safely,


~Rob


By Rob Auernig November 3, 2025
So, what has changed? Why is it increasingly difficult to make a claim? The California Department of Insurance (DOI) has promulgated regulations that the insurance companies MUST follow regarding claims handling practices. However, the DOI has almost no real authority to require the insurance companies to do anything. Therefore, insurance companies claim departments have learned that they can run roughshod over consumers, and there will be virtually no accountability thrust upon them. Furthermore, the regulations generally relate to the selling of insurance, and what is required of them after a claim is made. Very few regulations address the claims-making process other than timeframes that must be met by insurers. (Those often get trampled as well). Therefore, the claims-making process varies greatly from company to company. Add to that, cutbacks to personnel make even getting ahold of a claims representative sometimes challenging. And, when you do, you’re likely to find that the knowledge and professionalism of the personnel is greatly reduced from years past. Many insurance companies are now requesting that you send them photos so that they can “efficiently” initiate an estimate. That process in itself, can seem cumbersome (possibly by design…). Often, the result is an estimate for far lower than you could possibly get your vehicle repaired, which is yet another violation of regulations, but they do it anyway. Of course, they’ll explain that there may be “other damage” and that they’ll revisit it then. Often, their initial estimate is so low and below your deductible that it absolves them of any commitment at this time, or for a claimant, they hope that that miniscule amount is spent, and actual repairs are never pursued. Either way, the insurance company has set themselves up in manner that may greatly benefit them at the expense of the already financially injured party. DON’T LET THAT HAPPEN! If you’re the insured, you’ve already paid for your repairs (other than your chosen deductible amount). That’s what your premiums are. Don’t let them finagle you into paying twice! If you’re a claimant, then you deserve to be made whole. Don’t let them off the hook because they’ve made it intentionally difficult! In either case, we are here to help you through the process. At Auernig Auto Body, we realize that you are already in an undesirable position. Let’s face it, nobody wants to have to take their car into a body shop. We will do everything that we can to minimize your frustration and help you through this process while attempting to hold the insurance company accountable. (an ever-increasingly difficult task…) 😊 The old days of trusting your insurance company are over! Likely, best-case scenario is that you have two advocates in your corner… Hopefully, you are fortunate to have a good insurance agent. A good agent will get involved in the claims process, if need be, or at least help you to navigate its pitfalls. Your other advocate is Auernig Auto Body. We are one of the few shops left that choose to work for you, rather than the insurance companies. We will always put your interests ahead of those of the insurance company. I hope you find this helpful! Drive safely, Rob
By Rob Auernig September 29, 2025
Buying a Used Car? Here’s What We Recommend